Guest Stars Tiya Sircar as The Real Eleanor / Vicky / Denise Adam Scott as Trevor Sunita Mani as Chad Jackie Tohn as Alexis Emily Arlook as Dana Zeke Nicholson as Troy Co Starring Kaleigh Krause as Gayle / Jessica Seth Morris as Wallace Sarah Yarkin as Gloria Michelle Matule as Casey's Friend Max Silvestri as Dwayne DeRock Jordan Diggs as Todd Ele Woods as Casey