Guest Stars Nate Corddry as Gene Stuart Andrew Lawrence as Jason Maurio Valerie Mahaffey as Dr. Ocean Co Starring Ashley Bell as Tonya Rob Moran as Pastor Maurio J.R. Nutt as Demon Tour Guide Megan Hubbell as Girl Jeremy Radin as Doctor Elizabeth De Razzo as Angry Server Galeit Sehayek as Stage Manager Alexandria Foot as Goth Girl Rachelle Limback as 2nd Goth Girl Paul Distefano as Jesus