Guest Stars Mouzam Makkar as Jessica Kirsten Fitzgerald as Maria Walters Francis Guinan as Brother Simon Tim Hopper as Superintendent Jaffey Deanna Dunagan as Mother Bernadette Alan Metoskie as Red Brad Armacost as Bishop Donald Egan Carlos Rogelio Diaz as Reporter Ilyssa Fradin as Interviewer Aneisa Hicks as Tai Harris LaShawn Banks as Producer Michael Tatar as Trucker Hat Joby Earle as Clerk