Guest Stars Chris Agos as Assistant State's Attorney Steve Kot David Eigenberg as Lieutenant Christopher Herrmann Torrey DeVitto as Dr. Natalie Manning Nick Wechsler as Detective Kenny Rixton Carl Weathers as State's Attorney Mark Jefferies Zach Grenier as Father McSorley Dan Donohue as Russell Tillman Kyle Hatley as Travis James Co Starring Cisco Cotto as Reporter Lucien Cambric as Miles Vincent Nate Santana as Kirby Michaels Corr Kendricks as Little Dougie Robin E. Beaman as Parishoner #1 AJ Carr as T.J. Suellen Burton as Lisa Sims Ruth Mitchell as Parishoner #2 Noah Robinson as Jaylen Hines Autumn Joy as Jane Henderson Colleen O'Neill as Lara Michaels Wayne Benson as Eddie Ryan Angela Hearts-Glass as Miss Warner Terry Berner as Landlord Kennedy D. Leathers as Girl TJ Morris as Pro-McSorely Supporter Maria Jean Margaglione as Pro-Zoey Supporter