Guest Stars Scott Michael Foster as Nathaniel Plimpton III Michael McMillian as Tim Esther Povitsky as Maya Danny Jolles as George Burl Moseley as Jim Kittsworth Michael Hyatt as Dr. Akopian Rene Gube as Father Joseph / "Father Brah" Tovah Feldshuh as Naomi Bunch Rachel Grate as Audra Levine Patti LuPone as Rabbi Shari Co Starring Doug Mand as David Zach Reino as DJ
