Recurring Guest Characters Belle Starr 1 guest appearances Caleb Nash 1 guest appearances Jonathan Kale 1 guest appearances Vince Allard 1 guest appearances Arnold Braun 1 guest appearances Sheriff 1 guest appearances Joan Ransom 1 guest appearances Jacob Bronson 1 guest appearances Reb Haslett 1 guest appearances Hotel Manager 1 guest appearances Johnny Caldwell 1 guest appearances Cole Younger 1 guest appearances Reed 1 guest appearances