Recurring Guest Characters Michelle McNamara 7 guest appearances Patton Oswalt 6 guest appearances Paul Haynes 6 guest appearances Melanie Barbeau 5 guest appearances Michelle McNamara 5 guest appearances Larry Crompton 4 guest appearances Karen Kilgariff 4 guest appearances Kris Pedretti 4 guest appearances Paul Holes 4 guest appearances Billy Jensen 3 guest appearances Nancy Miller 3 guest appearances Fiona Williams 3 guest appearances Richard Shelby 3 guest appearances Sarah Stanard 3 guest appearances Gay Hardwick 3 guest appearances Bob Hardwick 3 guest appearances Jennifer Barth 3 guest appearances Daniel Greenberg 3 guest appearances Carol Daly 2 guest appearances Linda O'Dell 2 guest appearances ⇤ « 1 2 » ⇥