Special Guest Stars Misha Collins as Castiel Guest Stars Mark Sheppard as Crowley Curtis Armstrong as Metatron Alaina Huffman as Josie Sands / Abaddon Taylor Cole as Sarah Blake Graham Wardle as Tommy Collins Donnelly Rhodes as Father Simon Co Starring Cindy Busby as Jenny Klein Stephanie Bennett as Shelly Omari Newton as Peter Kent Demon Linda Tomassone as Nephilim Warren Kimmel as Father Max Thompson Annette Ducharme as Possessed Woman Al Miro as Young Father Simon Kavandeep Hayre as Chris the Clerk