Guest Stars Jill Flint as Diana Lindsay Alex Landi as Juror 1 Richard Litt as Judge Brisbee Minka Kelly as Kara Clayton Brian Stokes Mitchell as Perry Sinclair Ronald Guttman as Marcus Clayton John Rue as George Donahue Sarah Mack as Juror 39 Kyle Bary as Receptionist Mike Keller as Court Officer Anna Kathryn Holbrook as Juror 17