Guest Stars Amanda Leighton as Emma Kurtzman Jordan Rodrigues as Mat Tan Tom Williamson as AJ Hensdale Annika Marks as Monte Porter Alex Saxon as Wyatt Casey Elliot Fletcher as Aaron Baker Meg DeLacy as Grace Mullen Lisseth Chavez as Ximena Sinfuego Christopher Meyer as Logan Bayfield Nia Peeples as Susan Mullen Kristen Ariza as Tess Bayfield Anna Grace Barlow as Zoey Nick Fink as Shawn Kara Royster as Dawn Joi Liaye as Olivia Co Starring Nandy Martin as Poppy Sinfuego Adam Kang as Aiden Chris McGarry as Agent Allen Scott Broderick as Agent Estes / ICE Agent #1 Kathryn Winslow as Shiloh McCullen Alanna Fox as Counter Protester Marcos De Silvas as ICE Agent #2 Jay Brian Winnick as Prom Photographer Alfred Woodley as Police Officer Stephen Weigand as Pro-Shiloh Protester