Guest Stars Moshe Kasher as Dr. Harmon Goldberg Missi Pyle as Celery Savoy Bellacourt Thomas Lennon as Marquis de Sainsbury Kate Flannery as Annie Sullivan Shoshannah Stern as Helen Keller Erik Charles Nielsen as John John Rory Scovel as Men's Club Member Amanda Lund as Elisabeth Ossett Maria Blasucci as Hester Crowland Samm Levine as Men's Club Member Jared Breeze as Adolf Hitler Amy Hayes as Goody Vanderschmidt