Guest Stars Naomi Grossman as Pepper John Carroll Lynch as Twisty the Clown Grace Gummer as Penny Skyler Samuels as Bonnie Lipton Co Starring Mat Fraser as Paul the Illustrated Seal Erika Ervin as Amazon Eve Rose Siggins as Legless Suzi Jyoti Amge as Ma Petite Christopher Neiman as Salty Major Dodson as Corey Bachman Ben Woolf as Meep Mariana Paola Vicente as Waitress Carol Ashlynn Ross as Myrna Austin Lucy Faust as Joanne Miller Kristin Witt as Nurse Erica Curtis as Blonde Waitress Ramona Tyler as Mildred Bachman Lin Gathright as Sylvia Mills Amber Gaiennie as Elaine Seymore Thomas Francis Murphy as Mr. Haddonfield Andrew Duplessie as Troy Miller John Neisler as Dr. Hudson Ann Mckenzie as Eudora Tattler Ross Britz as Uniformed Officer Theresa Wasiloski as Plain Nurse Wilson Bradford as Bill Palmer Dane Rhodes as Det. Robert Bunch