Guest Stars Haley Tju as Rachelle Cohen-Strauss Andrew Jacobs as Ben Truax Chloë Levine as Jillian Larisa Oleynik as Shawn Nik Dodani as Chase Rao Jennifer Kim as Ms. Shaw Co Starring Munther Dajani as Ravi Nic Chase as Hayden (Soccer Bro) Anna Lynne Nelson as Katie Thomas Mor as Soccer Bro 2 Amy Newman as Front Desk Clerk Diane Kondrat as Aunt Claire Rigsby as Bridesmaid Eric Simons as Announcer Jonah Kersey as Server