Guest Stars Carlos Aviles as Mick Lauren Lapkus as Agent Phoebe Donnegan Zach Gilford as Greg Jonathan Silverman as Dave Sally Pressman as Nancy Shane Coffey as Kevin Andrew McCarthy as James Fitzpatrick Rodney To as Agent Henry Julian J. Gant as JT Ptolemy Slocum as Carl Audrey Wasilewski as Jenny Jimmy Fowlie as St. Anne's Parent Co Starring Everleigh McDonell as Jane Boland Danny Boyd Jr. as Harry Hill John Gloria as Officer Luke Potter Iyari Limon as Auctioneer Gina Hiraizumi as Well-Dressed Mom Gabby Lane as Retail Girl Tiffany C. Adams as Furniture Saleswoman Andrew Hill Newman as Chef Jerry Hernandez as Cop #1 Vayu O'Donnell as Apple Store Type Guy Monroe Robertson as Waiter