Guest Stars Carina Battrick as Caroline Cross Barbara Alyn Woods as Michelle Cross Devon Sawa as Logan Wheeler Michael Therriault as Nathan Cross Lexa Doig as Bree Wheeler Rachelle Casseus as Detective Evans Travis Milne as Detective Peyton Co Starring David Kohlsmith as Young Charles Lee Ray Avery Esteves as Oliver Hayden Jamillah Ross as Gladys Kravitz Lucas Misaljevic as Party Kid Amanda Cheung as Older Girl at Party Jaden Kwan as Party Kid 2 Erica Wood as Annie