Special Guest Stars Hilary Duff as Dylan Samuels Guest Stars Aaron Himelstein as Friedman Mark Totty as Det. Carlisle Patrick Fabian as Vice-Principal Gavin Price Annie Potts as Lt. Lucy Preston Juliette Goglia as Little Girl God Jared Hillman as Brian Beaumont Veanne Cox as Personable Woman God Lauren C. Mayhew as Elle Tyler Kain as Gabby Cheselka Leigh as Make-Up Lady God Co Starring Gina St. John as Professional Reporter #2 Mark Hames as Professional Reporter #1 Ron Michaelson as Stage Manager Kim Fifield as Indignant Girl Keith Bogart as Storm Summers Micah Stephen Williams as Nerdy Kid