Guest Stars Evan Ellison as Sebastian Zelle Jason Sakaki as Isaac Kimura Ty Wood as Teddy Harrington Marci T. House as Adele Thornton Laura Soltis as Cheryl Thurmond Djouliet Amara as Tatiana Nelson Caroline Cave as Abigail Dodd Co Starring Jennifer Copping as Captain Peck Heather Feeney as Purple-Robed Nun Arianna Bent as Angelica Alvin Sanders as Jerry Thomas Kyle Strauts as Birdman John Macanas as Resident Physician Alessandro Juliani as Bill Untermyer Sophia Bucior as Amontown Girl #1 Felicity Anne as Server Mike Ennis as Mechanic Bobby Stewart as Judge Jacob Neil Tiah Santucci as Young Amontown Girl Tobi Telford as County Counsel