Guest Stars Jessica Walter as Judith McKnight Richard Riehle as Walt Osorio Todd Louiso as Lyle Waznicki Mataeo Mingo as Lucas Matthew John Armstrong as Navy Seaman Michael Hayes Christopher Gartin as Jason Tupperman Iris Almario as Natalie Tupperman Joe Pistone as Prison Guard Lauren Bray as Makaela Hayes Nate Scholz as Former Navy Seaman Todd Bennett Paul Mabon as Lucas' Father Nick Toren as Dwight's Father Zeb Sanders as Dwight Jonathan Salisbury as Stephenson