Guest Stars Anabel Lee Telefoni as Baby Oliver Dawson Rainey as Baby Oliver Ever-Rome Fifita as Baby Oliver Emily Alexander as Baby Lily Chloe Alexander as Baby Lily Callie Pignone as Baby Enigma Lara Murphy Keevers as Baby Enigma Ellie Lang as Young Enigma Jacob Warner as Billy Thrumm Gus Murray as Nathan Emily Havea as Audrey Everly Bennett as Roxie Aubree Bennett as Roxie Roy Joseph as Nigel Justin Smith as Mr. Finch Paula Arundell as Libby Barbara Hastings as Enthused American, Deirdre Lachlan Masterson as Elliot Michelle Collins as Suburban Pamela Cardwell Lynch as Enthused American, Alan Lou Pollard as Nit-Witted Nancy Rob Flanagan as Barry Doughty James Vegter as Frank Imogen Gallagher as Ian's Daughter, Kaitlyn
