Guest Stars Mark Duplass as Brendan Deslaurier Anna Camp as Gwen Grandy Utkarsh Ambudkar as Rishi Lahiri Mary Grill as Maggie Kelen Coleman as Alex Stephanie Allynne as Tash Co Starring Mort Burke as Parker Jason Sims-Prewitt as Policeman Jillian Nelson as Jordan Briana Barran as Kara Joy Nash as Simone Elizabeth Moore as Catholic Lady Momo Casablanca as Creperie Clerk Ian Hutton as Chain Bartender Maurice Hall as Jimmy Royce Herron as Olga Blake Young-Fountain as Singing Waiter Katie Malia as Megyn