Special Guest Stars Paul Anka as Himself Guest Stars Michael Winters as Taylor Doose Sally Struthers as Babette Dell Emily Kuroda as Mrs. Kim Milo Ventimiglia as Jess Mariano Aris Alvarado as Caesar Alan Loayza as Colin McCrae Vanessa Marano as April Nardini Tanc Sade as Finn Nick Holmes as Robert Grimaldi Hayley McFarland as Marcia John Sloan as Matthew