Special Guest Stars James Van Der Beek as Tobias Hankel Guest Stars Meredith Monroe as Haley Hotchner Samantha Smith as Helen Wolf Muser as Samuel Jaime Ray Newman as Lacy Kyle Bill Smitrovich as Detective Farraday Cullen Douglas as Dr. Tony Wilson Todd Grinnell as Dennis Kyle Co Starring Brian Appel as Agent Anderson Gina Garcia Sharp as Agent Gina Sharp Dean Lemont as Agent Travis Green Don Swayze as Charles Hankel K'Sun Ray as Young Tobias Karl T. Wright as Ken McKinley Freeman as Agent Franks Keisha Alfred as Gayle Phinneas Kiyomura as Dart Player Tyler J. Olson as Handyman