Special Guest Stars Kerr Smith as Jack McPhee Meredith Monroe as Andrea "Andie" McPhee Monica Keena as Abby Morgan Mädchen Amick as Nicole Kennedy Rachael Leigh Cook as Devon Guest Stars Gareth Williams as Mike Potter Katy Selverstone as Pam Co Starring Karen Brigman as Gossiping Woman #1 Cynthia Stegner as Gossiping Woman #2