Guest Stars Leslie Silva as Judge Maya Lamkin John Ventimiglia as Dormit Ben Hollandsworth as Gil Foster Chris Beetem as John Phillips Co Starring Jade Wu as Judge Cara Bergen Karina Arroyave as Lurla Gray Lucca De Oliveira as Austin Becker Marcus Ho as Joe Mercado Jacob Berger as Police Officer Alex Danilov as Carter Phillips Stefanie Flores as Karen Rod Knoll as Arthur Jolene Jason Ostrowski as Coach Gary Nicole Beatty as Juror Geraldine Jason Boyle as Juror Peter Milly Guzman as Potential Juror #1 George Newton as Juror George