Guest Stars Morningstar Angeline as Martha Hawk Kimberly Guerrero as Falling Star Jim Beaver as Mr. Farber John Ales as Shelton Cape River Novin as Mountain Lion Lily Joy Winder as Flowers Co Starring Sarah Minnich as Alice Sumner Brandon Stacy as Levi Sumner Mark Sivertsen as Carson Krum Anna Nicole Silverstone as Izzie Sumner Adam Harvey as Male Posse Member Michael Momberg as Shoshone Warrior #1 Mark Parra as Shoshone Male Elder Karen R. Dixon as Shoshone Female Elder Kerry Graves as Charles Goodnight Bill Kostel as Sheriff Horace Bell David Pinter as Settler w/ Knife Julie Hanna as Female Posse Member Marc Comstock as Sullivan "Sully" Cooper Christopher Kriesa as JB Stone Casey Adams as Abel Grubs Teaguen Arbogast as Little Royal (Age 9)