Guest Stars Caroline Harris as Cora Love Michael Raymond-James as Ethan McPherson Steven Williams as Ray Cannon Sr. Susan Misner as Abby Deaver Ally Walker as Ms. Gaskins Shamika Cotton as Minister Keir O'Donnell as William Barlowe Jim Ferris as NYT Editor Pun Bandhu as Tony Simpson Tom Costello as Chris Peeler Co Starring Ja'Siah Young as Caleb Love Drew Allen as Capt. Gaylord Ellis E. Dawson as Rueben Kayla Cyphers as Lenna Cannon Erin E. Clyne as Sierra Cahill Dianne Garriga as Officer Lee Samantha Vosmaer as Officer Arnold Josephine Cardin-Vargo as Co-Pilot Vial David Leo as Deputy Marshal Baker Greg Alverez Reid as Deputy Marshal Helms Brittany Caswell as Ashlyn Cannon Ron Song as Carter Wynn Whit K. Lee as Officer Clark Turner Smith as John Eagen Jim O'Hare as Dan Doren Edward Chin-Lyn as Nolan Chambers Marie Marshall as Sgt. Shafer Cristos as Jose Salazar Adrienne D. Williams as Esther Mitch Poulos as Dept. Isiah Merrill