Guest Stars Kathryn Newton as Abigail Carlson Iain Armitage as Ziggy Chapman Darby Camp as Chloe Mackenzie Ivy George as Amabella Klein Merrin Dungey as Detective Adrienne Quinlan Santiago Cabrera as Joseph Bachman Kelen Coleman as Harper Stimson Robin Weigert as Dr. Amanda Reisman P.J. Byrne as Principal Nippal Gia Carides as Melissa Sarah Sokolovic as Tori Bachman Sarah Burns as Gabrielle Virginia Kull as Ms. Barnes Hong Chau as Jackie Sarah Baker as Thea Cunningham Joseph Cross as Tom Co Starring Cameron Crovetti as Josh Wright Chloe Coleman as Skye Carlson Nicholas Crovetti as Max Wright Larry Sullivan as Oren Larry Bates as Stu Kathreen Khavari as Samantha David Monahan as Bernard Joel Spence as Matt Tim True as Detective Walt Gibson Parker Croft as Brent Kimmy Shields as Kelly Stacie Greenwell as Lydia Ron Brooks as Detective Collins Jerome Holloway as Trivia Night Band Member Rob Banks as Trivia Night Band Member Daniel Yost as Trivia Night Band Member Eliot Lorango as Trivia Night Band Member Christopher Stills as Trivia Night Band Member Anne Dereaux as Trivia Night Backup Singer Wendy Wang as Trivia Night Backup Singer Jessica Reagans as Trivia Night Backup Singer