Special Guest Stars Norm Macdonald as Rusty Heck Guest Stars Jen Ray as Nancy Donahue Tommy Bechtold as Kenny Daniela Bobadilla as Lexie Brooks Alphonso McAuley as Hutch John Cullum as Big Mike Greer Grammer as April Co Starring Christine Garver as Colleen Aaron Hill as Dan Ty Chen as Scott Mary Gillis as Esther Jennie Fahn as Agatha Amir Levi as Bryan