Guest Stars Marque Richardson II as Reggie Green Caitlin Carver as Muffy Tuttle Brant Daugherty as Thane Lockwood Crystal-Lee Naomi as Karen Co Starring Sheridan Pierce as Abigail Kirsten Prout as Emily Lorynn York as Danielle Chinyere Dobson as Tanika Christina Cooper as Miko Ty Trumbo as Pegasus Guy Nirayl Stone as Tracey Alyssa Mann as Teacher Johanna Middleton as Charise Lucas McGarvey as Chad Rick Chambers as Newscaster Destiny Toliver as Toddler Girl Krista Lewis as Registration Clerk