Guest Stars Jack Coleman as Noah Bennet James Kyson as Ando Masahashi Zachary Quinto as Sylar Elizabeth Lackey as Janice Parkman Nora Zehetner as Eden McCain Matthew John Armstrong as Theodore Sprague Clea DuVall as FBI Agent Audrey Hanson Jayma Mays as Charlie Andrews Erick Avari as Chandra Suresh Stacy Haiduk as FBI Agent Elisa Thayer Shishir Kurup as Nirad Sakina Jaffrey as Mrs. Suresh Karri Turner as Lisa Kavi Ladnier as Mira Shenoy Co Starring Josh Clark as Sheriff Davidson Javin Reid as Sanjog Michael Maury as Lloyd Peyton Hinson as Waitress