Guest Stars Jack Coleman as Noah Bennet James Kyson as Ando Masahashi Zachary Quinto as Sylar Ashley Crow as Sandra Bennet Jimmy Jean-Louis as The Haitian Thomas Dekker as Zach Danielle Savre as Jackie Wilcox Nora Zehetner as Eden McCain Matt Lanter as Brody Mitchum Jayma Mays as Charlie Andrews Erick Avari as Chandra Suresh Shishir Kurup as Nirad Sakina Jaffrey as Mrs. Suresh Clay Wilcox as Gun Seller Co Starring Sally Champlin as Lynette Josh Clark as Sheriff Davidson Javin Reid as Sanjog Ryan K. Smith as Deputy Tiffany Hines as Cheerleader Ossie Mair as Vender Alan John Evrard as Utah Highway Patrol Brent Tarnol as Male Student Danielle Morrow as Everyday Girl Uncredited Karl T. Wright as Prinicipal Marks