Guest Stars Robert Knepper as Samuel Sullivan Elizabeth Lackey as Janice Parkman Dawn Olivieri as Lydia Madeline Zima as Gretchen Berg Tessa Thompson as Rebecca Taylor Rick Worthy as Mike Mark L. Young as Jeremy Greer Raphael Sbarge as Sheriff Werner Co Starring Erin Allin O'Reilly as Fire Breather Mom "Gale" Daryl Crittenden as Fire Breather Dad "Chris" Kaleigh Ryan as Fire Breather Daughter "Jennie" Candice Patton as Olivia Danica Stewart as Ashley Jonathan Goldstein as Male Citizen Randy Flagler as Deputy Gill Kat Purgal as Mask #2 Bonnie Bentley as Mask #1