Guest Stars Santiago Cabrera as Isaac Mendez Dawn Olivieri as Lydia Danielle Savre as Jackie Wilcox Elisabeth Röhm as Lauren Gilmore Jayma Mays as Charlie Andrews Co Starring Sally Champlin as Lynette Carlson Young as Cheerleader #5 Allison Paige as Cheerleader #6 Candace Smith as Miss Roberts Bryce Hurless as Pistol Petey Jessica Whitaker as Cheerleader #1 Lauren Hudson as Cheerleader #2 Danielle Crumble as Cheerleader #3 Deanna Douglas as Cheerleader #4