Guest Stars Chris Chalk as Gary Cooper Adina Porter as Kendra James Chris Messina as Reese Lansing David Harbour as Elliot Hirsch Grace Gummer as Hallie Shea Tara Summers as Bethany Brent Jennings as Judge Shelley Robertson as Margaret Rankin Co Starring Margaret Judson as Tess Westin John F. Carpenter as Herb Wilson Thomas Matthews as Martin Stallworth Trieu Tran as Joey Phan Charlie Weirauch as Jake Watson Riley Voelkel as Jennifer "Jenna" Johnson Jacy King as Trainer Lisa Temple as Angela Brand Mary Jane Wells as Josie Marks Kamel Haddad as Nabil Chatila Kurt Meyer as Floor Manager Santana Dempsey as Witness Jonny Bogris as Waiter Elisha Yaffe as Eddie Graham Sibley as Lawyer Richard Henning as John Bingham Jenny Phagan as Juror Tom Gatto as Restaurant Manager David Goryl as FBI Profiler