Guest Stars Angel Parker as Heidi Baker Patricia Belcher as Judge Horsedich Cristine Rose as Josie Davis Bob Gunton as Jeremiah Jefferson Davis Dave Allen as Dave the Taxidermist Lorna Scott as Suzie Julie Hagerty as Madame Rhonda Adam Shapiro as Harawitz Andie MacDowell as Margaret Henderson Co Starring Clint Culp as Bailiff Barry Livingston as Juror #1 Charles Emmett as Juror #2 John Hartman as Mitchell Loretta Shenosky as Edna the Stenographer Seth Coltan as Aaron Wilk