Guest Stars Alisha Wainwright as Maia Roberts Alan van Sprang as Valentine Morgenstern Will Tudor as Sebastian Verlac Vanessa Matsui as Dorothea "Dot" Rollins Lisa Berry as Sister Cleophas Co Starring Jack Fulton as Max Lightwood Elias Toufexis as Jonathan Zach Smadu as Elliot Jordan Johnson-Hinds as Gideon Rachelle Ganesh as Circle Member