Guest Stars Sarah Manninen as Mrs. Humphrey John Tench as Keeper #1 Jonathan Koensgen as Keeper #2 Elizabeth Saunders as Mrs. Honey Samantha Weinstein as Effie Kate Ross as Agnes Jonathan Goad as Grace's Father Mag Ruffman as Diane Christian Smith as Orderly Diane D'Aquila as Mrs. Quenell Michael Therriault as Mr. McDonald Alice Snaden as Miss Lydia Claire Armstrong as Cook Martha Burns as Mrs. Parkinson Evan Sabba as Tory #2 John Mallett as Asylum Doctor Alden Adair as Reformer #2 Scott Edgecombe as Tory #1 Kyle Cameron as Reformer #1 Zoe Begley as Claire Ian D. Clark as Catholic Priest Kirstin Rae Hinton as Grace's Mother Justin Sanchez as Street Drunk #2 Jacquelyn French as Female Prisoner Terry Parker as Street Drunk #1 Lawrence Cotton as Dr. Smith Christine Banquier as Katey Isaak Bailey as George Dylan Trowbridge as Ship's Doctor Jacob Soley as Michael Robert Persichini as Protestant Minister Kevin Fox as Guard #1 Patricia Phillips as Mrs. Phelan Michael Gordin Shore as Man on Ship