Guest Stars Aimée Laurence as Summer Lane Stephanie Hsu as Joy Sarita Choudhury as Lilith Asan Titus Makin, Jr. as Caleb Matthews Raúl Esparza as Jackson Neill William Popp as Harold Linus Co Starring Amy Lynn Sheehan as Monica Christopher Kelly as Young Steve Angus O'Brien as Logan Dodd Gio Solco as Young Cal Federico Rodriguez as Julian Dena Tyler as Claudia Lydia Gaston as Maria Taylor Selé as Alex Katelyn Pearce as Waitress Pamela Monroe as Woman Alan Ariano as Narciso Jimmy Gary, Jr. as Justin Max Sheldon as Simon Isabella Moore as Michaela Eliza Greene Smith as Principal