Guest Stars Ann Cusack as Olivia Trelawney Dave MacDonald as Ryan Springhill Bill Kelly as Officer Marlo Everett Co Starring Graeme Buffenbarger as Gerald Hartsfield Braxton Alexander as Young Brady Madison Bailey as Chloe Isaiah Stratton as Process Server Keith Flippen as Mr. Mundy Jacinte Blankenship as Beauty Parlor Manager James Werner as Sanj Christopher Gay as Carpenter Nicole Carpenter as Young Deborah Travis Sullivan as Young Norman Hartsfield