Guest Stars Linden Ashby as Sheriff Noah Stilinski JR Bourne as Chris Argent Melissa Ponzio as Melissa McCall Orny Adams as Coach Bobby Finstock Keahu Kahuanui as Danny Mahealani Nolan Godfrey as Lacrosse Player Vince Pisani as Ref Chris Thomas Hayes as Opposing Lacrosse Player Haley Roe Murphy as Laura Hale John Atwood as Math Teacher