Guest Stars Joe Grifasi as Judge Arlen Rand Kim Sykes as Judge Foley John Siciliano as Harrison Zack Abramowitz as Bailiff Kelvin Hale as Courthouse Guard Liza Colón-Zayas as ADA Jessica Goodman Sam Vartholomeos as Adam Harris Nell Verlaque as Emily Connor Casey Ford Alexander as Newsperson 1 Pamela Holden Stewart as Potential Juror 2 John Speredakos as Adam's Lawyer Lucy Taylor as Dawn Connor Rebecca Harris as Sally Harris Arnold Y. Kim as Potential Juror 1 Nadia Quinn as Ava's Mom Brian Dykstra as Doug Harris Jenni Graham as Juror 6 LeVera Sutton as Jury Foreman Austin Ku as Dr. James Muller Izzy Hanson-Johnston as Ava Simmons Gadi Rubin as Potential Juror 3 Matthew Lawler as Nathan Connor