Guest Stars Sammi Hanratty as Dollie Trask Stephen Lang as Increase Mather Co Starring Lara Grice as Mrs. Hale Mary Katherine O'Donnell as Emily Lucy Faust as Elizabeth Heaven Needham as Acolyte #1 Amber Dawn Landrum as Acolyte #2 Dane Rhodes as Henry Hopkins Michael Robert Brandon as Demon David Midthunder as Mohawk Richard Holden as Selectman Robert Ousley as Slave Ship Captain Santana Ruiz as Young Tituba