Guest Stars Tim Bagley as Toby Pearson Ryan Caltagirone as Hot Dad Jay Martel as Mr. Spinnoli Ithamar Enriquez as Dr. Lennon Kelly Schumann as Beverly Emily Walker as Judy Co Starring Aryan Simhadri as Danny Doris Guerrero as Brenda Rob Silverman as Richard Hamler Sapir Azulay as Estrella Christopher Sanders as Injured Soldier Matthew Bellows as Soldier in a Sling Ali Ghandour as Eugene Tara Jean O'Brien as Phyllis Jen Caldwell as Betty