Guest Stars Lesley Boone as Lucille Russo Kathleen Wilhoite as Phoebe Powell Co Starring David Alexander as Trotter Collins Euseph Messiah as Deputy Davis Currie Graham voices Glenn Peyton James D'Arcy voices English Muffin Enver Gjokaj voices Milk Carton Wynn Everett voices Pancakes Lorin McCraley as Hitchhiker Cynthia Barrett as Sweater Woman Taurean Blacque as Older Man Jacob Crawford as Man Richard Hempton as Man in Booth Monique Grant as Woman with Tight Braids Quita Culpepper as Anchorwoman Tamara Austin as Simone Lana Young as Judge Natalie Tomlinson