Guest Stars Caity Lotz as Sara Lance Celina Jade as Shado Roger Cross as Det. Lucas Hilton Bex Taylor-Klaus as Cindy "Sin" Simone Dylan Bruce as Adam Donner Teryl Rothery as Jean Loring Michael Eklund as Barton Mathis Co Starring Keri Adams as Bethany Snow Stefan Arngrim as Fence Chantele Francis as Court Clerk David Franco as Judge Mandlebaum Andy Thompson as Tony Daniel Jinji Mitchell as Dead Girl Owen Kwong as Dark Archer Ashley Marie Macdonald as Redhead Girl Sal Sortino as Vendor