Guest Stars Peter Cambor as Barry Tim Bagley as Peter Lindsey Kraft as Allison Giampietro-Smikowitz Jack Plotnick as Paul Marty Thomas as Charlie Megan Ferguson as Nadia Talia Shire as Teddie Mike Castle as Bobbie Co Starring Sarah Kay Jolly as Young Teddie Jack Fisher as Robin Judith Drake as Very Old Woman Riley Jackson as Young Frankie Mallory Portnoy as Gwendolyn Blart