Guest Stars Jazzy Williams as Anna Baker Frank Harts as ADA Madden Ivan Martin as Det. John Bradley Yolonda Ross as Judge Knight Adam David Thompson as Derrick Graham Laura Dale as Ashley Richardson James Francis Ginty as Josh O'Connor Co Starring A.Z. Kelsey as Matt Williams Maceo Oliver as Det. Rue Alia Guidry as Juror #4 Vin Knight as Leon Autumn Guzzardi as Waitress Wanda Nobles Colon as Juror #1 Renee Stork as Juror #2 Andrew L. Ricci as Juror #3 Sandra Marante as Juror #5 Julia Atwood as Katherine Graham Benjamin Bonenfant as Bartender