Guest Stars Sarah Chalke as Melanie Hertzal Juliette Angelo as Lauren Marshall Manesh as Juror #2 Anissa Borrego as New Agey Girl Andrew Patrick Ralston as Foreman John F. Schaffer as Donny Whitney Avalon as Barista Skyler Wright as High School Senior Sherry Mandujano as Courthouse Employee Thomas Silcott as Baliff Amir Levi as Juror Claire Liz Phillips as Disinterested Clerk Fredrick Burns as Judge Jennifer Naimo as Juror #3 Cristina Spruell as Madeline