Guest Stars Gbenga Akinnagbe as Tom Reyes Ruth Kearney as Daisy Locke Monique Gabriela Curnen as Erin Sloan Cotter Smith as Nathan Susan Kelechi Watson as Cindy Tim Guinee as Duncan Michael Gaston as Sheriff Windsor Allison Mack as Hillary Eric Nelsen as Justin Windsort Tobias Segal as Pat Elia Monte-Brown as Michelle Leeks Co Starring Kyle Barisich as FBI Agent Hopkins Anais Lee as Rose Nathanael Gilbert Small as Oliver Megan Byrne as Margo