Guest Stars Lara Jean Chorostecki as Toby's Mother Maya John Fleming as Young Toby Paulino Nunes as Mysterious Man Brendan Fletcher as Taz Patrick Garrow as Donald Conrad Bergschneider as Candyman Barbara Radecki as Julia Higgins Hayley Lochner as Ashley Higgins Robert Dodds as Dr. Melchior Tyler Stevenson as Andrew Higgins Richard Zwic as Magazine Guy